John
Cynthia Lennon's story is one that is been kept under the rug for years and is a story which has a strong possibility of captivating a wide audience whether they are fans of John Lennon or not. Cynthia let it all hang out in her book about "John", from the love they shared to her depression and anger towards John's treatment of their son Julian.
Whether you sympathize for Cynthia or not her book is well written and her story is well told. As I said earlier anyone can read this book, it is the perfect story of love, heartbreak, and a shocking ending. Cynthia goes into great detail about her relationship with John and her perspective of John throughout his life. She intertwines her life story with John's in fantastic ways seeing the true connections they shared from the time they met and the time John died.
The details of their relationship was something which was sort of under wraps unlike John's relationship with Yoko. The book is a really easy read and flows well. The book doesn't quite read like an autobiography since the focus of the story was about John of course so Cynthia does a pretty good job of leaving a lot of the minor details of her life which don't relate to John out of the story. She makes it clear that her love for John was strong and passionate and John's love for her was also extremely strong. Cynthia gives fantastic insight on John's personality like his extreme jealousy (Something which he told the world in "Jealous Guy") and his off the wall temper which could turn from happy and sincere to violent in seconds.
Even though John had blessed her with a life of extravagance for the years they spent together it is hard to deny the fact that John had treated her poorly and left her in a terrible situation. At times it seems like Cynthia makes herself out to be an all too good wife. The way she was able to forgive John for nearly anything and everything made me question her motives at times and whether or not she was truly as forgiving as she was. For instance, the way John had many affairs, he just played it off as something which was inevitable because women threw themselves at him so it was alright as long as they didn't mean anything. One thing that did feel truly authentic however, was her anger about the treatment of Julian which she harps on a lot and for good reason. She makes claims as saying how could the man who sang "Imagine", which makes claims that the world should "live as one", not even love and care for his own son. I think it really drives home the fact that you can't really effectively advocate for peace if you don't have peace within your life and that was John's major flaw.
Because Cynthia has been through so much regarding John her book needs to be taken with a grain of salt, she has a lot of pent up emotion which needed to be let out and she does so effectively. I was surprised by how captivated I was with this book and how it gave such a great perspective from a different side. By the time I was done I nearly hated the man who was sort of a hero to me. After some time away from the book I still look up to John and admire him for his work towards peace and his incredible song writing capabilities but this book did shed a more humane life on the issue of his personal relationship with Cynthia and Julian.


8 Comments:
Earlier in my life, I considered John Lennon to be the only famous person I had any desire to meet (even though this was probably about five years after he died). There is still a lot that I like about him like his edgey personality and his willingness to walk away from fame, but I don't think any of the good about him justifies his treatment of Cynthia and Julian. Now that I have two kids of my own, it baffles me even more that anything could take precedence over loving your child. Of all his accomplishments, none would have been so great as raising a child and he failed completely the first time around. It calls into question all his work for peace. How can he ask others to be peaceful when his treatment of Cynthia and Julian was anything but peaceful? So, now I have a love/hate relationship with John (or more accurately, my idea of John). I do think he made some efforts late in life to do right by Julian, but it ended up being too little, too late. I suppose it may not have been had Mark David Chapman not ended John's life so early.
Great coverage of the book. I can understand how people enjoy his music--he made some great music, after all--and respect his stance toward "the industry."
But it continues to astound me that anyone can hold him up as a hero or anything close. The things like his horrible temper (lack of self-control is far from a moral virtue), his treatment of Cynthia and Julian (deplorable), and his extreme jealousy (never an attractive trait) make me shake my head whenever anyone puts him up on a pedestal.
-- david
I like Julian's music. I remember getting one of his albums on casette for my birthday when I was a teenager (about 12 or 13). It was the one with his environmentalist Saltwater song. I felt it showed some of the same songwriting flair that John had. Not to mention Julian's voice is very similar to his father's. The album as a whole was quite enjoyable, I just wish I could remember the album title.
This does leave me curious, do Julian and Sean get along?
I am going to read it. Thank you for an excellent review, Jeff! You are a master at reviews, you really should get paid for this :)
I also like Julian's writing and singing. My mother thought "Valotte" was John when she heard it.
-- david
Bob - I think I share the same relationship that you do with Lennon. It is hard for me to hate him because I loved him all my life and he has done so much good. As you said though, there is no justification for what he has done in the past and at the end of the book Cynthia said that it really seemed like John was reaching out to have a better relationship with Julian but of course we never got to find out where the improvement would inevitably lead...
David - I understand what you're saying but I am one of those people that sort of put him up on a pedestal. I admire his dedication towards peace and his incredible song writing capablities. It's understandable why you would think like that though.
Perplexio - I never really got into Julian's music, it always sounded too 80's for me. I know Sean and Julian did get along but from what I remember in the book they drifted apart because of some event (If I recall corectly.) I don't know what their current status is.
Layla - I really enjoyed it, I think it is a good read for anyone.
David - I actually happen to like Sean more than Julian in terms of music. I really like his new CD "Friendly Fire."
Jeff - Sounds like a good read. Isn't it funny how much you really don't know about a person that you find out years later?
I wouldn't mind seeing a screenplay based off the book, but you know Yoko would never let that happen.
Peace,
- Neo
Neo - I think a movie on the book would be great, maybe you should make one!
Post a Comment
<< Home