If Video Killed the Radio Star Than What Killed the Video Star?
Not so much who killed the Video Star but who or what killed music on television. Music and television seemed to go hand in hand in the 80's and early 90's but towards the end of the 90's into the 2000's music and TV seemed to be polar opposites and this time opposites did not attract. Growing up in the music video era, MTV used to be the hot spot to hear some good and new music, now MTV is the perfect place to watch people embarrassing themselves on ridiculous dating shows. I'm not quite sure what Dating Mothers has to do with Music but maybe MTV (Music Television) knows something that I don't. The question is what happened to music and television? No longer do people even associate MTV with music, and even when we thought VH1 was going to hold its ground and continue playing music they went into the celebrity reality business. For me I feel there are two things that led to the destruction of music and TV.The first thing that led to the downfall of music and TV appears to me to be the diversity of music at this point in time. I don't think that ever in the history of music has there been such a large diversity. From Pop, to Rock, to Emo, to Rap, to Metal, to the Singer Songwriters and beyond leads me to believe that this is one important factor to the death of this once thriving business. Of course music has always been diverse but never to this point, even in times of heavy music diversity one genre always seemed to take the cake as the most popular especially during the 80's and earlier 90's. As of now with the immense diversity of genres the allocation of fans seems to be rather equal. Along with the diversity the discontent between genres seems to be rather heightened, those who listen to metal usually hate emo, those who listen to rock seem to hate rap, those who listen to nearly anything besides pop usually hate pop. With all this hate and diversity television just cannot win when playing music. If MTV were to play every genre then people would just flip in and out every few minutes if they stuck to just a certain genre they are losing a huge base of viewers. Regardless of what they do it is very difficult for them to come out victorious. The 80's was dominated by rock and hair bands, the early 90's was dominated by grunge. Rap was obviously around during this time but didn't quite break out the way it did in the later 90's. These non diverse times led to the perfect break out for both VH1 and MTV.
The second thing leading to the death I believe is the Internet. The power of the Internet was unleashed in the later 90's, no longer was music difficult to attain, with just an Internet connection music was just a click away. I don't honestly feel that the videos really drew people to watch MTV it was more or less the music. Of course the videos are nice to watch but it is the music that counts and why watch the TV waiting for a song you want to hear when you can just download it in a few seconds. If you want to make the argument that people do indeed want to watch the videos they are easier to attain than the music itself. Launch.com made an incredibly large database of music videos and once again why would one want to wait for a video they want to see when they can just hop on the internet and see what they want when they want. I once would badmouth MTV for no longer playing music but who can blame them. We are at a point in time where music and TV just don't go together. The Internet juxtaposed to TV for music is just a much more efficient option, and along with the Internet at this particular time in music history, the diversity of genres also leads to nothing but pain for TV and music.


7 Comments:
I've felt for awhile that the "turning point" for eMpTyV was around 1992. That's about when they hit their peak. They rode that peak but they also seemed to veer further and further away from music videos to focus on The Real World, Road Rules, Real World vs. Road Rules, TRL, Sweet 16, Real World vs. Road Rules vs. TRL Triple Threat, Headbangers Ball vs. Sweet 16, -- okay I'm exaggerating a bit on those last two-- but it has grown considerably more out of hand. VH1 actually seems WORSE! When even The Surreal Life is breeding spin-offs starring Flava Flav, Christopher Knight, and various other "stars" it's not exactly a sign of a prospering network. And what ever happened to those formulaic Behind the Music documentaries-- they may have been predictable, but they were interesting and at least still pertained to music!
Jeff - I agree with you. I also believe that for the most part there aren't anymore good bands/musician like there used to be. It's like they all copy one another.
MTV is dead as far as I'm concerned. They let the corporate/commerical world take them over. They started out being an independent venue for spotting hot acts and drawing people in to good tunes and great songs. I can't stand to stomach watching 10 seconds of it now.
I use winamp's shoutcase to get most of my video's these days. You should check winamp out if you don't already have it.
winamp.com
Peace,
- Neo
Jeff - That's shoutcast; not shoutcase, from winamp.
It's pretty sad when the only place one can see actual music videos is on a country music network. And even that is getting worse with this constant "coyote ugly search" that they insist on playing all the time.
I think you're absolutely right about the internet taking the place of TV in terms of bringing music to the people. MTV does play a little music, but not that much and when it does it's mostly rap and emo/metal or pop. VH1 seems to only play videos in the morning or on their countdown. I pity Matt Pinfield, but at the same time I'm happy for him because he would never be a VJ today on MTV with their image-conciousness. VH1, of course, mostly plays the stuff that the teens wouldn't understand or remember.
As usual, I don't know what my point is. I guess what I'm trying to say is that even when these networks play music, it's in very few formats. All the other genres you mentioned don't get played. There's also very little "buzz" about music videos. They aren't really "events" anymore, nor do they really give a lasting image for the song.
Ok, I'm done. I'd like to thank you for making this blog, a great place to have inteligent conversations about music! Even semi-mainstream stuff.
Perplexio - the Real World seemed to be the thing that began the gradual decline away from music and soon after each show detered from music.
Neo - MTV is so ridiculously corporate now. Commercials last for five minutes (probably longer) and that is only the beginning of it. Also I do use Winamp but I use the smallest version which basically just plays music, I'll look into the Shoutcast though.
Russ - I don't watch CMT but whenever I do pass it by I normally see music videos on it which I guess which keeps it the most pure of the music stations. You are right about the importance of videos now, when I hear songs like "Tonight Tonight" and "Smells Like Teen Spirit" I immediately think of the videos, no songs in the past five or so years have done that for me.
One thing that I didn't mention about MTV is that when they created MTV2 it was "supposed" to be the station that actually played music, from what I see it is just like MTV, no music and all crap.
Oh Jeff....what GREAT memories I have of the REAL MTV. The TV ads teased us for weeks, enticing us with ads of famous rock stars saying "I want my MTV!". I was sitting there at midnight when they came on air and it was the thing to watch for years.
But you are right...it's dead now. Totally dead.
(I have to sign on as my old self on here)
Hey Neo reads you! I didn't know that. He's a Rock Star. I've actually got him on my iPod.
Great to see ya back Layla! And yeah, Neo has been reading here. He's great, always has insightful things to say, I just might have to check out some of his stuff.
Post a Comment
<< Home